New Evidence on Mutual Fund Performance: A Comparison of Alternative Bootstrap Methods
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper compares the two bootstrap methods of Kosowski et al. (2006) and Fama and French (2010) using a new dataset on equity mutual funds in the UK. We find that: the average equity mutual fund manager is unable to deliver outperformance from stock selection or market timing, once allowance is made for fund manager fees and for a set of common risk factors that are known to influence returns; 95% of fund managers on the basis of the first bootstrap and almost all fund managers on the basis of the second bootstrap fail to outperform the zero-skill distribution net of fees; and both bootstraps show that there are a small group of “star” fund managers who are able to generate superior performance (in excess of operating and trading costs), but they extract the whole of this superior performance for themselves via their fees, leaving nothing for investors.
منابع مشابه
DISCUSSION PAPER PI-1405 Improved Inference in the Evaluation of Mutual Fund Performance using Panel Bootstrap Methods
Two new methodologies are introduced to improve inference in the evaluation of mutual fund performance against benchmarks. First, the benchmark models are estimated using panel methods with both fund and time effects. Second, the non-normality of individual mutual fund returns is accounted for by using panel bootstrap methods. We also augment the standard benchmark factors with fund-specific ch...
متن کاملPerformance Evaluation of Closed Ended Mutual Funds in Pakistan
Mutual funds are the best tool to mobilize savings and investments in an economy and Pakistan is the pioneer in South Asia, but this industry is not as much mature in comparison to its age in Pakistan. This paper examines the performance of closed ended mutual funds in Pakistan by using five different ranking measures during a period of January 2009 to December 2013 and the sample consists of o...
متن کاملStudying the Adjustment Amount of Ranking the Performance of Mutual Funds Based on Omega Ratio and Real Return
One of the main functionalities of capital market is to enhance liquidity in the market. Mutual funds are modern financial institutions which are designed with the aim of absorbing funds from investors and devote them to buy a variety of securities in order to reduce investment risks, exploit the economies of scale and finally make a reasonable return for investors. Regarding effective role of ...
متن کاملMutual Fund Performance: Evidence From the UK
This paper uses a large sample containing the complete return histories of 2300 UK openended mutual funds over a 23-year period to measure fund performance. We find some evidence of underperformance on a risk-adjusted basis by the average fund manager, persistence of performance and the existence of a substantial survivor bias. Similar findings have been reported for US equity mutual funds. New...
متن کاملAre Mutual Funds Doomed to Underperform? Evidence from Managerial Turnover and Fund Flows
We empirically investigate the impact of fund flows and managerial turnover on the investment performance of active equity mutual funds. Fund flows have been suggested by Berk and Green (2004) as mechanism that prevents performance persistence. We propose managerial turnover as an alternative explanation. One the one hand, withdrawing money from loser funds and sacking bad fund managers are mea...
متن کامل